PEH716
Title
PEH716
Hirsch Summary
A question is raised about why the tribe of Benjamin remained with Judah during the division of the Israelite United Kingdom into the kingdoms of Judah and Israel. The questioner explains that although God had decreed that one tribe should remain with Judah (1 Kings 11:32), Benjamin had many connections to Israel and stood in contrast to Judah. For instance, Jeroboam, from the tribe of Ephraim, who had common ancestry with Benjamin, led Israel. Additionally, during the desert wanderings, the tribes of Ephraim, Manasseh, and Benjamin formed a strategic unity known as the "camp of Ephraim." Furthermore, two leaders from Benjamin, Shimei ben Gera and Sheba ben Bichri, led the rebellion against David and the tribe of Judah. David ben Raphael Meldola gives seven reasons why Benjamin remained with Judah. Among them, he states that Judah vouched for Benjamin and that the end of the exile would come through the tribes of Judah and Benjamin because the Messiah would come from Judah and the prophet Elijah, his forerunner, from Benjamin.
Volume
9
Local
55
Written Date
1787-02-14
Published Date (est.)
1787-03-20
Author Short Name
Meldola
Author
Meldola, David ben Raphael
Rector Short Name
AcohenDav
Rector
Acohen d'Azevedo, David
Collection
Tags
Citation
“PEH716,” Pri Ets Haim Amsterdam Responsa, accessed July 6, 2025, https://pehh.library.utoronto.ca/items/show/11070.